For the past several years I have hemmed and hawed as to whether or not to get the flu shot. According to the CDC:
The single best way to protect against the flu is to get vaccinated each year. Key Facts About Seasonal Flu VaccineThere are two types of vaccines:
|
My main argument is how can you vaccinate against the flu... a virus?? My second argument is that the flu shot IS NOT a guarantee that you will not get the flu. This is because the flu shot is a scientists guess at the strain of the flu that is "most likely" to affect the population each year. Why would I willingly inject myself and my children with the dreaded flu? And really who's to say that the flu shot isn't just another media induced frenzy??
Let me tell you why my objections are valid. First, the flu is a virus; the only way for a virus to die is for it to be killed off by your body's natural defenses. There are no antibiotics, no cold medicines; no herbal remedies that will kill the virus, only time and a healthy immune system can help. Second, the fact that the flu shot is a guess is not good enough. It is impossible to predict with 100% accuracy every time, therefore there is only a chance that the same virus which you will get in the flu shot is the one you will get if you get the flu. Unless of course we are talking about the H1N1 vaccine, which is in fact composed of the H1N1 virus and will prevent you from getting the "swine flu". And I know that some of you are saying "Its not the live flu that you are being injected with!" But you know what; I'm not a fan of virus' living or dead.
Natural immunity is immunity that is acquired by your body as a result of fighting an illness successfully. This type of immunity is the only guarantee that you will not EVER get the same virus twice. The live nasal spray version of the "shot" is the only way that you can attain natural immunity as a result of the flu shot. Therefore with the most flu shot you will still feel the effects of the flu, just much milder than you would if you had acquired it on your own.
Here is another thing that frustrates me about the flu shot madness... it is now mandated by some employers (mainly hospitals) that employees get the flu shot, why are people allowing this to happen? It is such a violation of your rights. Not only that, but how about the people that get their flu shots and then immediately assume that not only are they not going to get sick, but that you are because you did not get it. And every time that my children get sick I am bombarded with people who ask… "Did they get their flu shot??" and when I answer "no" I am almost immediately looked at like a careless mother who's kids got sick because they did not get the flu shot. Guess what scornful supporters of the flu shot... my girlfriends son currently has this years flu... and guess what else... HE GOT THE SHOT!!! So there you go... maybe my children did get sick but at least it was out of my control.
Ok enough of my evil ranting... there are some benefits that I can find in support of the flu shot. One of which I learned in my microbiology class this year. The smallpox vaccine was created several years ago and eradicated smallpox. The smallpox vaccine was actually created from a strain of cowpox that was a close enough match that it prevented the smallpox as well and therefore allowed for people to develop immunity to smallpox. In light of this phenomenon I can see how the flu shot may have some benefits, and could potentially work. However that being said, it is still a gamble that I'm not willing to take.